April 16, 2012
Five years ago, Virginia Tech student Seung-Hui Cho had begun his mission of indiscriminate mass murder after leaving numerous vivid signs of his madness.
In the reckoning afterward, investigations identified many points along Cho's psychological disintegration where intervention might have averted the wide-awake nightmare of April 16, 2007 — the worst mass-shooting in U.S. history.
Today, with the benefit of hindsight and substantial legislative reforms, could someone else commit the same atrocity that Cho did when he shot 32 people dead and then killed himself as police closed in?
Gun Control Lobby
In Washington, D.C., survivors of the shooting and family members of the victims have made a push for stricter gun control laws.
They want the Senate to reject a plan that would allow people to buy guns online, so buyers can't get around gun laws by purchasing from a state with less restrictions. They also want members of Congress to sign a statement about keeping guns out of the hands of dangerous people.
The "Statement Of Principle Against Arming Dangerous People", presented by Dan Gross, president of the Brady Campaign, reads:
"I believe that these people should not be able to buy, own or carry a gun anywhere in our nation: Convicted felons, convicted domestic abusers, terrorists and people found to be dangerously mentally ill."
Members of the group also say that gun violence and death is 20 times higher in the United States than other developed countries.
At the University of Virginia, text and email alerts have become a more common occurrence.
"It feels good to know that they keep track of this and they email us as soon as they can," said 4th-year student Sarah Smith. "So it really does give a sense of safety, of community, that everyone here is looking out for everyone else."
Then-UVa. president John Casteen addressed the changes about a year after the shootings at Virginia Tech, saying, "We have established a permanent emergency management office. We are now installing a university-wide siren alert system."
Two of Virginia's most experienced law enforcement experts say it's extremely unlikely that another mass killing could occur, but impossible to rule out in a free society.
It's a question that haunts the unguarded corners of Col. Steve Flaherty's mind every day. The carnage he saw in Norris Hall — cell phones ringing in the pockets of slain students and faculty who would never answer them — is still unsettling and unshakable.
"It's the most horrific sight of my life," Flaherty, a career lawman and superintendent of the Virginia State Police since 2003, said barely above a whisper in a Friday telephone interview.
Everyone in Virginia changed a little that day, not just Flaherty. Not only do people remember where they were, what they were doing and whom they were with when they heard of the attack, it rocked basic assumptions about when and where they're really secure, said Flaherty's retired predecessor as head of the State Police, W. Gerald Massengill.
"It's like America before 9/11 and America after 9/11. Virginia since April 17, 2007, is different from Virginia on the morning of April 16, 2007, and before," said Massengill, who headed a blue-ribbon panel appointed to review the killings and recommend reforms.
Some of the holes in the system through which Cho passed have been patched. In addition to changes on college campuses, changes were made with lawmakers in Richmond.
"We saw where Mr. Cho had fallen through the cracks and we were able to identify some places where the hand off of his care hadn't been good. We re-wrote those laws entirely. It was the most sweeping overhaul in about 30 years," explained Delegate Rob Bell (R-58th).
Cho morphed from a quiet, bashful Tech freshman in 2003 into a seething madman by 2007, alarming fellow students and professors alike with dark and violent writings. Mental health professionals evaluated Cho overnight in December 2005 and deemed him imminently dangerous to himself and others. Police ordered Cho not to contact a female Tech student who had received disturbing emails, text messages and even a personal visit from him.
Now, Virginia's publicly supported colleges and universities are required by law to have teams that investigate the academic, medical and criminal records of troubled students such as Cho and establish rules and regimens for dealing with them.
"We changed some of the rules for when someone can get out of treatment. Those are some of the rules we looked at right after this, because the thought was, we can't prevent all problems but we certainly try to make sure that this particular problem doesn't happen again," Bell said.
Cho never should have been able to buy the two handguns he used to carry out his execution-style killings from licensed gun dealers. Because a court had ordered him to undergo mental health testing, his name should have appeared in a database licensed gun dealers use to vet the backgrounds of firearms purchasers. His name was not there.
Then-Gov. Tim Kaine ordered an administrative fix to that problem, and the General Assembly quickly wrote it into state law in 2008.
Yet there's nothing to prevent the mentally unstable, felons or anyone else from obtaining firearms at Virginia's gun shows — bazaars where gun enthusiasts can sell, swap and barter weapons with no questions asked. Virginia's pro-gun legislature has repeatedly defeated efforts to close the "gun show loophole."
"I continue to be very worried about that," said Kaine, who left office in 2010 and, after two years as Democratic National Committee chairman, is running for an open U.S. Senate seat.
"Cho didn't buy guns at a gun show, but people who have adjudicated histories of dangerous mental illness, people who are felons, it is illegal for them to get weapons in the absence of a simple and easy records check," Kaine said.
Other work also remains.
Kaine says it's important not to underfund community mental health services — the first lines of defense against a future killer like Cho.
Massengill said privacy laws still impede information sharing between classrooms, courtrooms, police departments and mental health professionals in cooperatively — and confidentially — dealing with troubled students.
Virginia Tech's deaths, to be mourned at a campus candlelight vigil Monday, were not in vain, Flaherty said.
Campuses across the nation learned to immediately alert their students via emails, text messages or broadcasts to trouble on or near campus. Two fateful hours lapsed at Virginia Tech after Cho killed his first two victims in a dormitory until he entered Norris Hall, chained and locked its doors and began shooting.
Maybe things are better. Certainly, it would be improbable that someone like Cho could amass so high a toll again on a Blacksburg campus — or anywhere else — now much more on guard.
It's cold comfort to Beth Hilscher. Her daughter, Emily Jane, a 19-year-old freshman, was among Cho's first victims, shot dead in her dormitory early that morning alongside Ryan Clark, a fellow Hokie who rushed to her aid.
"Could it happen again? Sure it could. It just happened last week in California," she said Friday.
One Goh, a 43-year-old student at Oikos University, is charged with murder in the shooting deaths of seven people on the Oakland campus April 2. Police say Goh was angry with a school administrator over a financial dispute and began shooting others when he learned she was not there.
"Even if everything else had gone right at Virginia Tech the rest of the day on April 16, 2007, it would have been a bad day for Emily and Ryan," Beth Hilscher said. "But there are still students who have mental illness and who are still being ignored."
The comments sections of Newsplex.com are designed for thoughtful, intelligent conversation and debate. We want to hear from our viewers, but we only ask that you use your best judgment. E-mail is required, but will not be displayed with comment.
As a host Newsplex.com welcomes a wide spectrum of opinions. However this is a site that we host. We have a responsibility to all our readers to try to keep our comment section fair and decent. For that reason The Newsplex reserves the right to not post or to remove any comment.
If you have any ideas to improve the conversation or this section let us know. Send an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org.
powered by Disqus